Assessing the Effectiveness of a Computer Simulation in Introductory Undergraduate Environments
Author(s)
<vcard>BEGIN:vCard\nVERSION:3.0\nFN:C. J. Keller\nORG:University of Colorado at Boulder\nADR;TYPE=WORK,POSTAL,PARCEL:;;University of Colorado at Boulder;390 UCB, Physics;Boulder;CO;80309;US\nTEL;TYPE=Office:+303-492-5735\nEMAIL;:kellercj@Colorado.EDU\nEND:vCard</vcard><vcard>BEGIN:vCard\nVERSION:3.0\nFN:Noah D. Finkelstein\nTITLE:\nORG:University of Colorado-Boulder\nADR;TYPE=WORK,POSTAL,PARCEL:;;UCB 390;;Boulder;CO;80309;US\nTEL;TYPE=Office:+(303) 735-6082\nTEL;TYPE=:+\nTEL;TYPE=FAX:+\nEMAIL;TYPE=INTERNET,Work:noah.finkelstein@colorado.edu\nEMAIL;TYPE=INTERNET,:\nEND:vCard</vcard>
<vcard>BEGIN:vCard\nVERSION:3.0\nFN:Katherine K. Perkins\nTITLE:\nORG:University of Colorado\nADR;TYPE=WORK,POSTAL,PARCEL:;;Department of Physics;390 UCB;Boulder;CO;80309;US\nTEL;TYPE=Office:+(303) 492-6714\nTEL;TYPE=:+\nTEL;TYPE=FAX:+\nEMAIL;TYPE=INTERNET,Work:katherine.perkins@colorado.edu\nEMAIL;TYPE=INTERNET,:\nEND:vCard</vcard>
<vcard>BEGIN:vCard\nVERSION:3.0\nFN:Steven J. Pollock\nTITLE:\nORG:University of Colorado\nADR;TYPE=WORK,POSTAL,PARCEL:;;Department of Physics;University of Colorado;Boulder;CO;80309;US\nTEL;TYPE=:+\nTEL;TYPE=:+\nTEL;TYPE=FAX:+\nEMAIL;TYPE=INTERNET,:\nEMAIL;TYPE=INTERNET,:\nEND:vCard</vcard>
Keywords
computer aided instructioneducational aids
computer aided analysis
teaching methods
CCK
Circuit Construction Kit
PERC 2006
General Physics
Physics Education Research
Education Practices
Technology
Full record
Show full item recordOnline Access
http://www.compadre.org/Repository/document/ServeFile.cfm?ID=5272&DocID=2120https://dx.doi.org/10.1063/1.2508707
Abstract
We present studies documenting the effectiveness of using a computer simulation, specifically the Circuit Construction Kit (CCK) developed as part of the Physics Education Technology Project (PhET), in two environments: an interactive college lecture and an inquiry-based laboratory. In the first study conducted in lecture, we compared students viewing CCK to viewing a traditional demonstration during Peer Instruction. Students viewing CCK had a 47% larger relative gain (11% absolute gain) on measures of conceptual understanding compared to traditional demonstrations. These results led us to study the impact of the simulation's explicit representation for visualizing current flow in a laboratory environment, where we removed this feature for a subset of students. Students using CCK with or without the explicit visualization of current performed similarly to each other on common exam questions. Although the majority of students in both groups favored the use of CCK over real circuit equipment, the students who used CCK without the explicit current model favored the simulation more than the other group.Type
Reference MaterialIdentifier
oai:compadre.org:5272http://www.compadre.org/Repository/document/ServeFile.cfm?ID=5272&DocID=2120
http://dx.doi.org/10.1063/1.2508707
compadre.org:5272
Copyright/License
Has a copyright or other licensing restriction.Collections
Related items
Showing items related by title, author, creator and subject.
-
Evaluating a model of research-based practices for teacher preparation in a physics department: Colorado PhysTEC<vcard>BEGIN:vCard\nVERSION:3.0\nFN:Noah D. Finkelstein\nTITLE:\nORG:University of Colorado-Boulder\nADR;TYPE=WORK,POSTAL,PARCEL:;;UCB 390;;Boulder;CO;80309;US\nTEL;TYPE=Office:+(303) 735-6082\nTEL;TYPE=:+\nTEL;TYPE=FAX:+\nEMAIL;TYPE=INTERNET,Work:noah.finkelstein@colorado.edu\nEMAIL;TYPE=INTERNET,:\nEND:vCard</vcard>; <vcard>BEGIN:vCard\nVERSION:3.0\nFN:Chandra Turpen\nORG:University of Colorado-Boulder\nADR;TYPE=WORK,POSTAL,PARCEL:;;Department of Physics;UCB 390;Boulder;CO;80309;US\nTEL;TYPE=Office:+303-735-0458\nEMAIL;TYPE=INTERNET,Work:chandra.turpen@colorado.edu\nEND:vCard</vcard>; <vcard>BEGIN:vCard\nVERSION:3.0\nFN:Steven J. Pollock\nTITLE:\nORG:University of Colorado\nADR;TYPE=WORK,POSTAL,PARCEL:;;Department of Physics;University of Colorado;Boulder;CO;80309;US\nTEL;TYPE=:+\nTEL;TYPE=:+\nTEL;TYPE=FAX:+\nEMAIL;TYPE=INTERNET,:\nEMAIL;TYPE=INTERNET,:\nEND:vCard</vcard>; <vcard>BEGIN:vCard\nVERSION:3.0\nFN:Michael Dubson\nTITLE:\nORG:University of Colorado Boulder\nADR;TYPE=WORK,POSTAL,PARCEL:;;UCB 390;;Boulder;CO;80309;US\nTEL;TYPE=:+\nTEL;TYPE=:+\nTEL;TYPE=FAX:+\nEMAIL;TYPE=INTERNET,:\nEMAIL;TYPE=INTERNET,:\nEND:vCard</vcard>; <vcard>BEGIN:vCard\nVERSION:3.0\nFN:Steve Iona\nADR;TYPE=WORK,POSTAL,PARCEL:;;;;;;;US\nEND:vCard</vcard>; <vcard>BEGIN:vCard\nVERSION:3.0\nFN:C. J. Keller\nORG:University of Colorado at Boulder\nADR;TYPE=WORK,POSTAL,PARCEL:;;University of Colorado at Boulder;390 UCB, Physics;Boulder;CO;80309;US\nTEL;TYPE=Office:+303-492-5735\nEMAIL;:kellercj@Colorado.EDU\nEND:vCard</vcard>; <vcard>BEGIN:vCard\nVERSION:3.0\nFN:Valerie K. Otero\nTITLE:\nORG:University of Colorado at Boulder\nADR;TYPE=WORK,POSTAL,PARCEL:;;249 UCB;;Boulder;CO;80309-0249;US\nTEL;TYPE=Office:+303-492-7403\nTEL;TYPE=:+\nTEL;TYPE=FAX:+303-492-7090\nEMAIL;TYPE=INTERNET,Work:valerie.otero@colorado.edu\nEMAIL;TYPE=INTERNET,:\nEND:vCard</vcard>We describe and evaluate the first year efforts of the Colorado Physics Teacher Education Coalition (Colorado PhysTEC), which is designed to increase the number and quality of preparation of future pre-college physics teachers. The Colorado PhysTEC program partners the Department of Physics, the School of Education, and other University of Colorado programs (particularly STEM-Colorado), with local schools and K-12 physics teachers. We report on efforts to engage students in transformed teaching practices, programs to create educational partnerships among all of the participants, and research that documents local educational practices and larger features of sustainable and scalable educational transformations.
-
Developing and Researching PhET simulations for Teaching Quantum Mechanics<vcard>BEGIN:vCard\nVERSION:3.0\nFN:Sam B. McKagan\nTITLE:\nORG:JILA\nADR;TYPE=WORK,POSTAL,PARCEL:;;University of Colorado, Boulder;JILA, UCB 440;Boulder;CO;80309;US\nTEL;TYPE=Office:+303-492-7815\nTEL;TYPE=:+\nTEL;TYPE=FAX:+\nEMAIL;TYPE=INTERNET,Work:mckagan@colorado.edu\nEMAIL;TYPE=INTERNET,:\nEND:vCard</vcard>; <vcard>BEGIN:vCard\nVERSION:3.0\nFN:Katherine K. Perkins\nTITLE:\nORG:University of Colorado\nADR;TYPE=WORK,POSTAL,PARCEL:;;Department of Physics;390 UCB;Boulder;CO;80309;US\nTEL;TYPE=Office:+(303) 492-6714\nTEL;TYPE=:+\nTEL;TYPE=FAX:+\nEMAIL;TYPE=INTERNET,Work:katherine.perkins@colorado.edu\nEMAIL;TYPE=INTERNET,:\nEND:vCard</vcard>; <vcard>BEGIN:vCard\nVERSION:3.0\nFN:Michael Dubson\nTITLE:\nORG:University of Colorado Boulder\nADR;TYPE=WORK,POSTAL,PARCEL:;;UCB 390;;Boulder;CO;80309;US\nTEL;TYPE=:+\nTEL;TYPE=:+\nTEL;TYPE=FAX:+\nEMAIL;TYPE=INTERNET,:\nEMAIL;TYPE=INTERNET,:\nEND:vCard</vcard>; <vcard>BEGIN:vCard\nVERSION:3.0\nFN:Chris Malley\nORG:PixelZoom, Inc.\nADR;TYPE=WORK,POSTAL,PARCEL:;;835 Orman Dr.;;Boulder;CO;80309;US\nTEL;TYPE=Office:+(303) 494-8849\nEMAIL;TYPE=INTERNET,Work:cmalley@pixelzoom.com\nEND:vCard</vcard>; <vcard>BEGIN:vCard\nVERSION:3.0\nFN:Sam Reid\nTITLE:\nORG:University of Colorado, Boulder\nADR;TYPE=WORK,POSTAL,PARCEL:;;;;Boulder;CO;80309;US\nTEL;TYPE=:+\nTEL;TYPE=:+\nTEL;TYPE=FAX:+\nEMAIL;TYPE=INTERNET,:\nEMAIL;TYPE=INTERNET,:\nEND:vCard</vcard>; <vcard>BEGIN:vCard\nVERSION:3.0\nFN:Ron LeMaster\nORG:University of Colorado, Boulder\nADR;TYPE=WORK,POSTAL,PARCEL:;;;;Boulder;CO;80309;US\nEND:vCard</vcard>; <vcard>BEGIN:vCard\nVERSION:3.0\nFN:Carl E. Wieman\nTITLE:\nORG:Stanford University\nADR;TYPE=WORK,POSTAL,PARCEL:;;;;;;;\nTEL;TYPE=Office:+\nTEL;TYPE=:+\nTEL;TYPE=FAX:+\nEMAIL;TYPE=INTERNET,Work:\nEMAIL;TYPE=INTERNET,:\nEND:vCard</vcard>Quantum mechanics is difficult to learn because it is counter-intuitive, hard to visualize, mathematically challenging, and abstract. The Physics Education Technology (PhET) Project, known for its interactive computer simulations for teaching and learning physics, now includes 18 simulations on quantum mechanics designed to improve learning of this difficult subject. Our simulations include several key features to help students build mental models and intuitions about quantum mechanics: visual representations of abstract concepts and microscopic processes that cannot be directly observed, interactive environments that directly couple students' actions to animations, connections to everyday life, and efficient calculations so students can focus on the concepts rather than the math. Like all PhET simulations, these are developed using the results of education research and feedback from educators, and are tested in student interviews and classroom studies. This article provides an overview of the PhET quantum simulations and their development. We also describe research demonstrating their effectiveness and share some insights about student thinking that we have gained from our research on quantum simulations.
-
Physics I MOOC - Educational Outcomes<vcard>BEGIN:vCard\nVERSION:3.0\nFN:David Lieberman\nORG:CUNY/Queensborough Community College\nADR;TYPE=WORK,POSTAL,PARCEL:;;;;Bayside;NY;11364;US\nEND:vCard</vcard>; <vcard>BEGIN:vCard\nVERSION:3.0\nFN:Michael Dubson\nTITLE:\nORG:University of Colorado Boulder\nADR;TYPE=WORK,POSTAL,PARCEL:;;UCB 390;;Boulder;CO;80309;US\nTEL;TYPE=:+\nTEL;TYPE=:+\nTEL;TYPE=FAX:+\nEMAIL;TYPE=INTERNET,:\nEMAIL;TYPE=INTERNET,:\nEND:vCard</vcard>; <vcard>BEGIN:vCard\nVERSION:3.0\nFN:Ed Johnsen\nORG:University of Colorado at Boulder\nADR;TYPE=WORK,POSTAL,PARCEL:;;UCB 390;;Boulder;CO;80309;US\nEND:vCard</vcard>; <vcard>BEGIN:vCard\nVERSION:3.0\nFN:Jack Olsen\nORG:University of Colorado at Boulder\nADR;TYPE=WORK,POSTAL,PARCEL:;;UCB 390;;Boulder;CO;80309;US\nEND:vCard</vcard>; <vcard>BEGIN:vCard\nVERSION:3.0\nFN:Noah D. Finkelstein\nTITLE:\nORG:University of Colorado-Boulder\nADR;TYPE=WORK,POSTAL,PARCEL:;;UCB 390;;Boulder;CO;80309;US\nTEL;TYPE=Office:+(303) 735-6082\nTEL;TYPE=:+\nTEL;TYPE=FAX:+\nEMAIL;TYPE=INTERNET,Work:noah.finkelstein@colorado.edu\nEMAIL;TYPE=INTERNET,:\nEND:vCard</vcard>While enrollment and retention figures often grab headlines for Massively Open Online Courses (MOOCs), the more telling measures of MOOCs’ effectiveness may be found in the educational outcomes. The performance of students enrolled in the University of Colorado Physics I MOOC was evaluated with the use of numerous instruments. These instruments include exams, homework assignments, the FMCE and the CLASS. The performance of students in the MOOC was tracked across the semester and compared with that of students in similar “Brick and Mortar” classes at the University of Colorado. For some measures (FMCE) their performance was compared with the results from large scale studies. On all measures the MOOC students performed at least as well as and had learning gains at least as great as those in more traditional settings including interactive engagement. This may be due, in part, to a massive self-selection process skewing the MOOC population over time.