Improving Effectiveness and Outcomes for the Poor in Health, Nutrition, and Population : An Evaluation of World Bank Group Support since 1997
Author(s)
Independent Evaluation GroupKeywords
HEALTH PROGRAMSPOPULATION GROUPS
COST-EFFECTIVENESS
HEALTH IMPACTS
AIDS RELIEF
CONTRACEPTIVE USE
MALARIA
NUTRITIONAL STATUS
HEALTH INSURANCE
HOSPITAL
MINISTRIES OF HEALTH
HEALTH RESULTS
POVERTY REDUCTION
EPIDEMIC
HEALTH CONDITIONS
IMPACT EVALUATIONS
HEALTH OUTCOMES
WOMAN
SOCIAL SAFETY NETS
INVENTORY
HEALTH INSURERS
INTERNATIONAL COMMUNITY
INTERNATIONAL CONSENSUS
MILLENNIUM DEVELOPMENT GOALS
RURAL AREAS
HEALTH NEEDS
ACCESS TO FAMILY PLANNING
HEALTH SYSTEMS STRENGTHENING
CHILD HEALTH
SANITATION
DEVELOPMENT POLICY
HEALTH SYSTEM
HEALTH PROJECTS
UNIVERSAL ACCESS
MILLENNIUM DEVELOPMENT GOAL
POLITICAL SUPPORT
INFANTS
HEALTH INFORMATION SYSTEMS
HUMAN DEVELOPMENT
HUMAN REPRODUCTION
DEMOGRAPHIC CHANGE
LABOR MARKETS
HOSPITALS
HEALTH REFORMS
HEALTH CARE PROVISION
DISCUSSION OF POPULATION
LOCAL CAPACITY
MALARIA INCIDENCE
REPRODUCTIVE HEALTH PROGRAMS
SOCIAL SECURITY
ALLOCATION OF RESOURCES
DEMOGRAPHIC TRANSITION
INTERNATIONAL COOPERATION
STRATEGIC PRIORITIES
PEACE
QUALITY OF SERVICES
HEALTH CARE
MATERNAL CARE
FAMILY PLANNING
COMMUNICABLE DISEASES
HEALTH FINANCING
PUBLIC INSURANCE
POOR PEOPLE
HEALTH SECTOR
REPRODUCTIVE HEALTH
GLOBAL DEVELOPMENT
MINISTRIES OF FINANCE
COMMUNICABLE DISEASE CONTROL
MANAGEMENT INFORMATION SYSTEMS
REORGANIZATION
PREPAYMENT SCHEMES
SOCIAL IMPACT
RURAL DEVELOPMENT
MARGINAL COSTS
CHILDREN PER WOMAN
POLICY DIALOGUE
SUSTAINABLE ACCESS
REFUGEES
SUBSIDIARY
DEVELOPING COUNTRIES
MALARIA CONTROL
EMERGENCY PLAN
POLIO
INFANT MORTALITY
ECONOMIC GROWTH
NATIONAL HEALTH EXPENDITURES
AGING
HEALTH FINANCE
GOOD GOVERNANCE
SCREENING
MINISTRY OF HEALTH
DISSEMINATION
ILLNESS
INSURANCE SCHEMES
CLIMATE CHANGE
TRUST FUNDS
TECHNICAL ASSISTANCE
HIGH FERTILITY
EXTERNALITIES
PUBLIC INSURANCE SCHEMES
INCOME
INCOME GROUPS
HUMAN IMMUNODEFICIENCY VIRUS
PORTFOLIO ANALYSIS
MANDATES
EMERGING MARKETS
TRANSPORT
PROBABILITY
HEALTH PROBLEMS
HEALTH SERVICES
CAPACITY BUILDING
POPULATION SECTOR
TRANSACTION COSTS
SAFE WATER
HEALTH STATUS
EXERCISES
HEALTH INVESTMENTS
CHILD MORTALITY
DEVELOPMENT OBJECTIVES
HYGIENE
INTERVENTION
HIV/AIDS
MEDICAL EDUCATION
POOR HEALTH
CIVIL SOCIETY ORGANIZATIONS
HEALTHY DEVELOPMENT
LIFE INSURANCE
PRIVATE SECTOR
PRIVATE SECTORS
PUBLIC HEALTH SPENDING
MORBIDITY
POLICY MAKERS
WATER SUPPLY
PUBLIC SECTOR
HEALTH EXPENDITURES
INFANT NUTRITION
EPIDEMIOLOGY
HOUSEHOLD SURVEYS
HEALTH FUNDING
ACCOUNTABILITY
LOW-INCOME COUNTRIES
CITIES
HEALTH PROVIDERS
FINANCE MINISTRIES
NATIONAL LEVEL
GOVERNMENT CAPACITY
HEALTH IMPACT
PILOT PROJECTS
LONG-TERM CARE
INFANT
INSTITUTIONAL CAPACITY
HEALTH STRATEGY
PROFITABILITY
HEALTH-SECTOR
LEGAL STATUS
FINANCIAL CRISES
CARE FOR CHILDREN
USE OF HEALTH SERVICES
EARLY CHILDHOOD
RISK GROUPS
HEALTH SYSTEM PERFORMANCE
DEVELOPMENT ASSISTANCE
REGULATORY FRAMEWORKS
HUMAN RESOURCES
INSTITUTIONAL MECHANISMS
PUBLIC EXPENDITURE
PROGRESS
WORLD HEALTH ORGANIZATION
FERTILITY RATE
UNDER-FIVE MORTALITY
SEXUALLY TRANSMITTED DISEASES
NATIONAL STRATEGY
GENERIC DRUGS
NATIONAL HEALTH
BANKS
ILL HEALTH
TUBERCULOSIS
PUBLIC HEALTH
AGED
MATERNAL MORTALITY
INFORMATION SYSTEM
QUALITY ASSURANCE
FINANCIAL PROTECTION
INFECTIOUS DISEASES
IMMUNODEFICIENCY
PRIVATE HEALTH INSURANCE
DOCTORS
SELF-ASSESSMENT
HEALTH REFORM
INCIDENCE OF POVERTY
GOVERNMENT LEADERSHIP
MORTALITY
NUTRITION
INFANT MORTALITY RATES
DECENTRALIZATION
SAFETY NET
HEALTH INFORMATION
CHILD SURVIVAL
PRIVATE HOSPITALS
HEALTH INTERVENTIONS
HEALTH SYSTEM REFORM
VITAL STATISTICS
GLOBAL REPRODUCTIVE HEALTH
HEALTH SYSTEM STRENGTHENING
HEALTH ORGANIZATION
HIV
SERVICE DELIVERY
INSTITUTIONAL DEVELOPMENT
HEALTH SYSTEMS
Full record
Show full item recordOnline Access
http://hdl.handle.net/10986/2645Abstract
This evaluation aims to inform the implementation of the most recent the World Bank and International Finance Corporation (IFC) health, nutrition, and population (HNP) strategies to enhance the effectiveness of future support. It covers the period since fiscal year 1997 and is based on desk reviews of the portfolio, background studies, and field visits. The evaluation of the HNP support of the World Bank focuses on the effectiveness of policy dialogue, analytic work, and lending at the country level, while that of IFC focuses on the performance of health investments and advisory services before and after its 2002 health strategy. The themes it covers are drawn from the two strategies and the approaches adopted by international donors in the past decade. Independent Evaluation Group (IEG) has previously evaluated several aspects of the Bank's HNP support. IFC's support for the health sector has never been fully evaluated. Many lessons have been learned over the past decade about the successes and pitfalls of support for health reform: First, the failure to assess fully the political economy of reform and to prepare a proactive plan to address it can considerably diminish prospects for success. Political risks, the interests of key stakeholders, and the risk of complexity- issues the evaluation case studies found to be critical are often neglected in risk analysis in project appraisal documents for health reform projects. Second, reforms based on careful prior analytic work hold a greater chance of success, but analytic work does not ensure success. Third, the sequencing of reforms can improve political feasibility, reduce complexity, ensure that adequate capacity is in place, and facilitate learning. When implementation is flagging, the Bank can help preserve reform momentum with complementary programmatic lending through the Ministry of Finance, as it did in Peru and the Kyrgyz Republic. Finally, monitoring and evaluation are critical in health reform projects-to demonstrate the impact of pilot reforms to garner political support, but also because many reforms cannot work without a well-functioning management information system.Date
2012-03-19Identifier
oai:openknowledge.worldbank.org:10986/2645978-0-8213-7950-9
http://hdl.handle.net/10986/2645
Copyright/License
Creative Commons Attribution CC BY 3.0Related items
Showing items related by title, author, creator and subject.
-
Expanding Health Coverage for Vulnerable Groups in IndiaNagpal, Somil (World Bank, Washington, DC, 2013-05-02)India's health sector continues to be challenged by overall low levels of public financing, entrenched accountability issues in the public delivery system, and the persistent dominance of out-of-pocket spending. In this context, this case study describes three recent initiatives introduced by the central and state governments in India, aimed at addressing some of these challenges and improving the availability of and access to health services, particularly for the poor and vulnerable groups in the country. This includes two federal schemes introduced by the Government of India-the National Rural Health Mission (NRHM) of the Ministry of Health and Family Welfare and the Rashtriya Swasthya Bima Yojana (RSBY) of the Ministry of Labor and Employment-and the Rajiv Aarogyasri scheme launched by the state government of Andhra Pradesh. The three schemes discussed in this case study were designed and implemented by different agencies almost in parallel, over the same time period, and used different financing and delivery approaches. A discussion of the mechanics and operational features of these programs has been undertaken to unravel the underlying complexities, interactions, and interdependencies of these programs within the country's health system. The remainder of this case study on India's march toward universal health coverage focuses on three recent, prominent programs, and includes a discussion on the institutional structure of these programs and their interactions within the country's health system, their mechanisms for beneficiary targeting and enrolment, the benefits packages covered by them, accompanying innovations in public financial management, and their information environment. Annex one presents an overview of the health system and health financing in India, and annex two discusses the evolutionary context of India's Government sponsored health insurance schemes. The discussion of the mechanics and operational features of these programs has been undertaken to unravel the underlying complexities, interactions, and interdependencies within these programs. The case study also aims to contribute to the ongoing debate within the Indian health sector, with opinions divided between investments in traditional input-based health spending for publicly managed health facilities versus demand-side financing, purchasing of care, and involving private providers and intermediaries in delivering services financed by public money. The case study also aims to share how the lessons learned by one program can be applicable more widely within the Indian health system and beyond
-
Integrating the Poor into Universal Health Coverage in VietnamTien, Tran Van; Somanathan, Aparnaa; Dao, Huong Lan (World Bank, Washington DC, 2013-05-06)This case study is aimed at providing a descriptive assessment of the key features of Vietnam's Social Health Insurance (SHI), focusing on the impediments to integrating the poor into universal coverage. The trajectory of SHI in Vietnam is similar to that of many other countries in the East Asia and Pacific region. The poor were covered under a separate Health Care Fund for the Poor to begin with. The 2009 Law on Health Insurance merged all of the different programs into one. Health insurance premiums for the poor were fully subsidized by the government and enrolment became mandatory, resulting in almost complete enrollment of the poor by 2011. Vietnam has combined elements of contributory social health insurance with substantial levels of tax financing to provide coverage for the poor and informal sector. The case study is structured as follows. Section 2 describes the institutional structure and system characteristics of Vietnam's SHI. Section 3 addresses the main topic of the case study - the impediments to integrating the poor. Section 4 concludes by addressing the pending agenda.
-
Good Practices in Health Financing : Lessons from Reforms in Low and Middle-Income CountriesWaters, Hugh R.; Schieber, George J.; Gottret, Pablo (Washington, DC : World Bank, 2012-05-25)This volume focuses on nine countries that have completed, or are well along in the process of carrying out, major health financing reforms. These countries have significantly expanded their people's health care coverage or maintained such coverage after prolonged political or economic shocks. In doing so, this report seeks to expand the evidence base on good performance in health financing reforms in low- and middle-income countries. The countries chosen for the study were Chile, Colombia, Costa Rica, Estonia, the Kyrgyz Republic, Sri Lanka, Thailand, Tunisia, and Vietnam. With health at the center of global development policy on humanitarian as well as economic and health security grounds, the international community and developing countries are closely focused on scaling up health systems to meet the Millennium Development Goals (MDGs), improving financial protection, and ensuring long-term financing to sustain these gains. With the scaling up of aid, both donors and countries have come to realize that money alone cannot buy health gains or prevent impoverishment due to catastrophic medical bills. This realization has sent policy makers looking for reliable evidence about what works and what does not, but they have found little to guide their search.