How Bad Is Depression? Preference Score Estimates from Depressed Patients and the General Population
Contributor(s)Center for Behavioral and Decision Sciences in Medicine, Ann Arbor VAMC and University of Michigan, Ann Arbor, MI ,
Center for Mental Healthcare and Outcomes Research (152/NLR), Central Arkansas Veterans Healthcare System, North Little Rock, AR 72114 ,
Center for Mental Healthcare and Outcomes Research (152/NLR), Central Arkansas Veterans Healthcare System, North Little Rock, AR ,
Psychiatric Research Institute, University of Arkansas for Medical Sciences, Little Rock, AR ,
Center for Health Research, Northwest/Hawai'i/Southeast, Kaiser Permanente Northwest Region, Portland, OR ,
Health Economics and Decision Science, School of Health and Related Research, Sheffield, UK.
Full recordShow full item record
AbstractTo compare depression health state preference scores across four groups: (1) general population, (2) previous history of depression but not currently depressed, (3) less severe current depression, and (4) more severe current depression. Data Sources . Primary data were collected from 95 general population, 163 primary care, and 83 specialty mental health subjects. Study Design . Stratified sampling frames were used to recruit general population and patient subjects. Subjects completed cross-sectional surveys. Key variables included rating scale and standard gamble scores assigned to depression health state descriptions developed from the Patient Health Questionnaire-9 (PHQ-9) and SF-12. Data Collection/Extraction Methods . Each subject completed an in-person interview. Forty-nine subjects completed test/retest reliability interviews. Principal Findings . Depressed patient preference scores for three of six SF-12 depression health states were significantly lower than the general population using the rating scale and two of six were significantly lower using standard gamble. Depressed patient scores for five of six PHQ-9 depression health states were significantly lower than the general population using the rating scale and two of six were significantly lower using standard gamble. Conclusions . Depressed patients report lower preference scores for depression health states than the general population. In effect, they perceived depression to be worse than the general public perceived it to be. Additional research is needed to examine the implications for cost-effectiveness ratios using general population preference scores versus depressed patient preference scores.
Pyne, Jeffrey M.; Fortney, John C.; Tripathi, Shanti; Feeny, David; Ubel, Peter; Brazier, John (2009). "How Bad Is Depression? Preference Score Estimates from Depressed Patients and the General Population." Health Services Research 44(4): 1406-1423. <http://hdl.handle.net/2027.42/74065>
Health Services Research
Adang, E. M., G. Kootstra, G. L. Engel, J. P. van Hooff, and H. L. Merckelbach. 1998. ??? Do Retrospective and Prospective Quality of Life Assessments Differ for Pancreas???Kidney Transplant Recipients? ??? Transplant International 11 ( 1 ): 11 ??? 5.
Alloy, L. B., and L. Y. Abramson. 1979. ??? Judgment of Contingency in Depressed and Nondepressed Students: Sadder but Wiser? ??? Journal of Experimental Psychology: General 108 ( 4 ): 441 ??? 85.
Badia, X., A. Diaz-Prieto, M. Rue, and D. L. Patrick. 1996. ??? Measuring Health and Health State Preferences among Critically Ill Patients.??? Intensive Care Medicine 22 ( 12 ): 1379 ??? 84.
Balaban, D. J., P. C. Sagi, N. I. Goldfarb, and S. Nettler. 1986. ??? Weights for Scoring the Quality of Well-being Instrument among Rheumatic Arthritics.??? Medical Care 24 ( 11 ): 973 ??? 80.
Barney, L. J., K. M. Griffiths, A. F. Jorm, and H. Christensen. 2006. ??? Stigma about Depression and Its Impact on Help-Seeking Intentions.??? Australian and New Zealand Journal of Psychiatry 40 ( 1 ): 51 ??? 4.
Beck, M., S. Dietrich, H. Matschinger, and M. C. Angermeyer. 2003. ??? Alcoholism: Low Standing with the Public? Attitudes towards Spending Financial Resources on Medical Care and Research on Alcoholism.??? Alcohol and Alcoholism 38 ( 6 ): 602 ??? 5.
Boyd, N., H. Sutherland, K. Heasman, D. L. Tritchler, and B. J. Cummings. 1990. ??? Whose Utilities for Decision Analysis? ??? Medical Decision Making 10 ( 1 ): 58 ??? 67.
Brauer, C. A., A. B. Rosen, D. Greenberg, and P. J. Neumann. 2006. ??? Trends in the Measurement of Health Utilities in Published Cost???Utility Analyses.??? Value in Health 9 ( 4 ): 213 ??? 18.
Brazier, J., R. Akehurst, A. Brennan, P. Dolan, K. Claxton, C. McCabe, M. Sculpher, and A. Tsuchyia. 2005. ??? Should Patients Have a Greater Role in Valuing Health States? ??? Applied Health Economics and Health Policy 4 ( 4 ): 201 ??? 8.
Brazier, J., M. Deverill, C. Green, R. Harper, and A. Booth. 1999. ??? A Review of the Use of Health Status Measures in Economic Evaluation.??? Health Technology Assessment 3 ( 9 ): i ??? iv, 1???164.
Brazier, J., J. Roberts, and M. Deverill. 2002. ??? The Estimation of a Preference-Based Measure of Health from The SF-36.??? Journal of Health Economics 21 ( 2 ): 271 ??? 92.
Brazier, J., T. Usherwood, R. Harper, and K. Thomas. 1998. ??? Deriving a Preference-Based Single Index from the UK SF-36 Health Survey.??? Journal of Clinical Epidemiology 51 ( 11 ): 1115 ??? 28.
De Wit, G. A., J. J. Busschbach, and F. T. De Charro. 2000. ??? Sensitivity and Perspective in the Valuation of Health Status: Whose Values Count? ??? Health Economics 9 ( 2 ): 109 ??? 26.
Dolders, M. G., M. P. Zeegers, W. Groot, and A. Ament. 2006. ??? A Meta-Analysis Demonstrates No Significant Differences between Patient and Population Preferences.??? Journal of Clinical Epidemiology 59 ( 7 ): 653 ??? 64.
Drummond, M. F., B. O'Brien, G. L. Stoddart, and G. W. Torrance. 1997. Methods for the Economic Evaluation of Health Care Programmes. 2nd Edition. New York: Oxford University Press.
Fleiss, J. L. 1986. The Design and Analysis of Clinical Experiments. New York: John Wiley & Sons.
Froberg, D. G., and R. L. Kane. 1989a. ??? Methodology for Measuring Health-State Preferences???II: Scaling Methods.??? Journal of Clinical Epidemiology 42 ( 5 ): 459 ??? 71.
Froberg, D. G., and R. L. Kane. 1989b. ??? Methodology for Measuring Health-State Preferences III: Population and Context Effects.??? Journal of Clinical Epidemiology 42 ( 6 ): 585 ??? 92.
Furlong, W., D. Feeny, G. W. Torrance, R. Barr, and J. Horsman. 1990. Guide to Design and Development of Health-State Utility Instrumentation. Hamilton, ON, Canada: McMaster University.
Gabriel, S. E., T. S. Kneeland, L. J. Melton III, M. M. Moncur, B. Ettinger, and A. N. Tosteson. 1999. ??? Health-Related Quality of Life in Economic Evaluations for Osteoporosis: Whose Values Should We Use? ??? Medical Decision Making 19 ( 2 ): 141 ??? 48.
Gold, M. R., J. E. Siegel, L. B. Russell, and M. C. Weinstein. 1996. Cost-Effectiveness in Health and Medicine. New York: Oxford University Press Inc.
Green, C., J. Brazier, and M. Deverill. 2000. ??? Valuing Health-Related Quality of Life. A Review of Health State Valuation Techniques.??? PharmacoEconomics 17 ( 2 ): 151 ??? 65.
Insinga, R. P., and D. G. Fryback. 2003. ??? Understanding Differences between Self-Ratings and Population Ratings for Health in the EuroQOL.??? Quality of Life Research 12 ( 6 ): 611 ??? 9.
Kaplan, R. M. 2005. ??? The Minimally Clinically Important Difference in Generic Utility-Based Measures.??? Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease 2 ( 1 ): 91 ??? 7.
Katon, W. J., M. Schoenbaum, M. Y. Fan, C. M. Callahan, J. Williams Jr., E. Hunkeler, L. Harpole, X. H. Zhou, C. Langston, and J. Unutzer. 2005. ??? Cost-Effectiveness of Improving Primary Care Treatment of Late-Life Depression.??? Archives of General Psychiatry 62 ( 12 ): 1313 ??? 20.
Kroenke, K., R. L. Spitzer, and J. B. Williams. 2001. ??? The PHQ-9 Validity of a Brief Depression Severity Measure.??? Journal of General Internal Medicine 16 ( 9 ): 606 ??? 13.
Lazarus, R. S., and S. Folkman. 1984. Stress, Appraisal, and Coping. New York: Springer.
Lenert, L. A., J. R. Treadwell, and C. E. Schwartz. 1999. ??? Associations between Health Status and Utilities Implications for Policy.??? Medical Care 37 ( 5 ): 479 ??? 89.
Link, B. G., J. C. Phelan, M. Bresnahan, A. Stueve, and B. A. Pescosolido. 1999. ??? Public Conceptions of Mental Illness: Labels, Causes, Dangerousness, and Social Distance.??? American Journal of Public Health 89 ( 9 ): 1328 ??? 33.
Llewellyn-Thomas, H., H. J. Sutherland, R. Tibshirani, A. Ciampi, J. E. Till, and N. F. Boyd. 1984. ??? Describing Health States: Methodologic Issues in Obtaining Values for Health States.??? Medical Care 22: 543 ??? 52.
Macran, S., and P. Kind. 2001. ?????? ???Death??? and the Valuation of Health-Related Quality of Life.??? Medical Care 39 ( 3 ): 217 ??? 27.
Matheson, K., and H. Anisman. 2003. ??? Systems of Coping Associated with Dysphoria, Anxiety and Depressive Illness: A Multivariate Profile Perspective.??? Stress 6 ( 3 ): 223 ??? 34.
McKie, J., and J. Richardson. 2003. ??? The Rule of Rescue.??? Social Science and Medicine 56 ( 12 ): 2407 ??? 19.
National Institute for Clinical Excellence. 2004. ???Guide to the Methods of Technology Appraisal??? [accessed on January 2, 2008]. Available at http://www.nice.org.uk/niceMedia/pdf/TAP_Methods.pdf
Perry, B. L., B. A. Pescosolido, J. K. Martin, J. D. McLeod, and P. S. Jensen. 2007. ??? Comparison of Public Attributions, Attitudes, and Stigma in Regard to Depression among Children and Adults.??? Psychiatric Services 58 ( 5 ): 632 ??? 5.
Postulart, D., and E. M. M. Adang. 2000. ??? Response Shift and Adaption in Chronically Ill Patients.??? Medical Decision Making 20: 186 ??? 93.
Pyne, J. M., S. Tripathi, D. K. Williams, and J. Fortney. 2007. ??? Depression-Free Day to Utility-Weighted Score: Is It Valid? ??? Medical Care 45 ( 4 ): 357 ??? 62.
Rashidi, A. A., A. H. Anis, and C. A. Marra. 2006. ??? Do Visual Analogue Scale (VAS) Derived Standard Gamble (SG) Utilities Agree with Health Utilities Index Utilities? A Comparison of Patient and Community Preferences for Health Status in Rheumatoid Arthritis Patients.??? Health and Quality of Life Outcomes 4: 25.
Revicki, D. A., A. Shakespeare, and P. Kind. 1996. ??? Preferences for Schizophrenia-Related Health States: A Comparison of Patients, Caregivers and Psychiatrists.??? International Clinical Psychopharmacology 11 ( 2 ): 101 ??? 8.
Sackett, D. L., and G. W. Torrance. 1978. ??? The Utility of Different Health States as Perceived by the General Public.??? Journal of Chronic Diseases 31: 697 ??? 704.
Schoenbaum, M., J. Unutzer, C. Sherbourne, N. Duan, L. V. Rubenstein, J. Miranda, L. S. Meredith, M. F. Carney, and K. Wells. 2001. ??? Cost-Effectiveness of Practice-Initiated Quality Improvement for Depression: Results of a Randomized Controlled Trial.??? Journal of the American Medical Association 286 ( 11 ): 1325 ??? 30.
Schomerus, G., H. Matschinger, and M. C. Angermeyer. 2006. ??? Preferences of the Public Regarding Cutbacks in Expenditure for Patient Care: Are There Indications of Discrimination against Those with Mental Disorders? ??? Social Psychiatry and Psychiatric Epidemiology 41 ( 5 ): 369 ??? 77.
Seligman, M. E. P. 1998. Learned Optimism: How to Change Your Mind and Your Life. New York: A.A. Knopf.
Sherbourne, C. D., J. Unutzer, M. M. Schoenbaum, N. Duan, L. A. Lenert, R. Sturm, and K. B. Wells. 2001. ??? Can Utility-Weighted Health-Related Quality-of-Life Estimates Capture Health Effects of Quality Improvement for Depression? ??? Medical Care 39 ( 11 ): 1246 ??? 59.
Simon, G. E., W. J. Katon, M. VonKorff, J. Unutzer, E. H. Lin, E. A. Walker, T. Bush, C. Rutter, and E. Ludman. 2001. ??? Cost-Effectiveness of a Collaborative Care Program for Primary Care Patients with Persistent Depression.??? American Journal of Psychiatry 158 ( 10 ): 1638 ??? 44.
Smith, D. M., R. L. Sherriff, L. Damschroder, G. Loewenstein, and P. A. Ubel. 2006. ??? Misremembering Colostomies? Former Patients Give Lower Utility Ratings Than Do Current Patients.??? Health Psychology 25 ( 6 ): 688 ??? 95.
Sugar, C. A., R. Sturm, T. T. Lee, C. D. Sherbourne, R. A. Loshen, K. B. Wells, and L. A. Lenert. 1998. ??? Empirically Defined Health States for Depression from the SF-12.??? Health Services Research 33 ( 4 ): 911 ??? 28.
Tsevat, J., N. V. Dawson, A. W. Wu, J. Lynn, J. R. Soukup, E. F. Cook, H. Vidaillet, and R. S. Phillips. 1998. ??? Health Values of Hospitalized Patients 80 Years or Older. HELP Investigators. Hospitalized Elderly Longitudinal Project.??? Journal of the American Medical Association 279 ( 5 ): 371 ??? 5.
Ubel, P. A., G. Loewenstein, and C. Jepson. 2003. ??? Whose Quality of Life? A Commentary Exploring Discrepancies between Health State Evaluations of Patients and the General Public.??? Quality of Life Research 12 ( 6 ): 599 ??? 607.
Ubel, P. A., G. Loewenstein, N. Schwarz, and D. Smith. 2005. ??? Misimagining the Unimaginable: The Disability Paradox and Health Care Decision Making.??? Health Psychology 24 ( 4, suppl. ): S57 ??? 62.
Walters, S. J., and J. E. Brazier. 2003. ??? What Is the Relationship between the Minimally Important Difference and Health State Utility Values? The Case of the SF-6D.??? Health and Quality of Life Outcomes 1: 4.
Ware, J. Jr., M. Kosinski, and S. D. Keller. 1996. ??? A 12-Item Short-Form Health Survey: Construction of Scales and Preliminary Tests of Reliability and Validity.??? Medical Care 34 ( 3 ): 220 ??? 33.