Consent to research by mentally ill children and adolescents : the implications of Chapter 9 of the National Health Act
Author(s)Nienaber, A.G. (Annelize Gertruida)
KeywordsMentally ill children -- South Africa
Mentally ill adolescents
Clinical trials -- Law and legislation -- South Africa
South Africa. National Health Act, 2012
Psychiatry -- Research -- South Africa
Medical ethics -- South Africa
National Health Act
Full recordShow full item record
AbstractChapter 9 of the National Health Act came into effect in March 2012. In this article, the Act’s statutory requirements relating to the informed consent to participation in clinical research by mentally ill children and adolescents in South Africa are examined. The necessity of doing clinical research in mentally ill children and adolescents is canvassed briefly and the requirements that chapter 9 sets out for lawful child and adolescent consent to research participation are presented. Furthermore, the limitations of the newly enacted legislation is deliberated upon and selective improvements are proposed. Because of the likely erosion of the minor’s privacy, the requirement that a parent or legal guardian must consent to children’s and adolescents’ participation in research has the potential to obstruct much-needed mental health research. This requirement is likely to be found unconstitutional. In certain circumstances, ethics committees tasked with the review of research should be allowed to dispense with parental consent, and adolescents recognised as having the necessary capacity to consent independently to research participation. Furthermore, the Act’s classification of research into therapeutic and non-therapeutic categories is considered problematic. It is recommended that research permissible in minors be stated in terms of well-defined risk standards. Finally, the requirement set in subsection 71(3) for ministerial consent in the case of non-therapeutic research in children and adolescents is found to be overly protectionist, as it precludes the capacity of ethics committees to judge the ethics of the proposed research.
Nienaber, A 2013, 'Consent to research by mentally ill children and adolescents : the implications of Chapter 9 of the National Health Act', South African Journal of Psychiatry, vol. 19, no. 1, pp. 19-23.
Copyright/LicenseHealth and Medical Publishing Group
Showing items related by title, author, creator and subject.
Guidelines for parents, teachers and professionals in the handling of rebellious childrenRoets, H. E. (Hester Elizabeth); Mathye, Lethabo Violet (2015-01-23)Rebelliousness is the act of defying lawful authority or a resistant way of relating to authority.
It is seen by many as a normal way of development.
The development of rebellious behavior actually starts in childhood and progresses through
The study focuses on the manner in which the family and school handle the rebellious child and the negative effects that these have on the child's development. These problems may manifest in truancy, delinquency, negativism, runaway, antisocial behavior, alcohol and substance abuse and gang involvement.
The results of the study prove that the environment in which the adolescent lives, contribute greatly to the development and the maintenance of rebellious
Guidelines were written for parents, teachers and psychologists regarding the handling of the