Sustainability of Healthcare Financing in the Western Balkans : An Overview of Progress and Challenges
Keywords
EFFICIENCY OF PUBLIC SPENDINGHOSPITALS
PHARMACEUTICAL EXPENDITURES
OUTPATIENT SERVICES
CENTRAL BUDGET
HEALTHCARE SERVICES
PUBLIC REVENUES
PUBLIC EXPENDITURE
HEALTH INSURANCE SCHEME
LABOR MARKETS
PHARMACEUTICAL SECTOR
PHYSICIANS
HEALTH INSURANCE COVERAGE
CAPITATION PAYMENTS
PUBLIC HEALTH SPENDING
REIMBURSEMENT SYSTEMS
PHARMACISTS
HEALTHCARE PROVIDERS
PRIVATE HEALTH INSURANCE
MACROECONOMIC STABILIZATION
REVENUE SOURCES
DEBT
MEDICAL EDUCATION
PRIVATE SPENDING
HEALTH EXPENDITURE
HOSPITAL MANAGEMENT
ILLNESS
CAPITATION
INSURANCE PACKAGE
HEALTH CARE UTILIZATION
HEALTH SERVICES
CANCER PATIENTS
BUDGETARY FUNDS
HEALTHCARE EXPENDITURE
REIMBURSABLE DRUGS
BUDGETARY RESOURCES
HEALTH INSURANCE SCHEMES
POLICY RESEARCH
PAYROLL TAXES
LIVING STANDARDS
PREGNANT WOMEN
CAPITA HEALTH EXPENDITURE
NATIONAL HEALTH INSURANCE FUND
HEALTH MINISTRIES
AGING POPULATIONS
NURSING
HOSPITAL BEDS
PHARMACY
HEALTH CARE FINANCING
NURSES
HEALTH DATA
SOCIAL HEALTH INSURANCE SCHEMES
PUBLIC HEALTHCARE
POLICY DECISIONS
FINANCIAL PROTECTION
HEALTHCARE SYSTEM
PATIENTS
EQUITY IN ACCESS
CASH PAYMENTS
PRIVATE SECTOR
HEALTH ORGANIZATION
PATIENT
MIGRATION
REFUGEES
HEALTH CARE
NUTRITION
PHYSICIAN
HEALTH INSURANCE CONTRIBUTIONS
FISCAL SUSTAINABILITY
INFORMAL PAYMENTS
PATIENT SATISFACTION
FINANCIAL PLANNING
GENERAL PRACTITIONERS
NATIONAL HEALTH INSURANCE
MEDICAL EQUIPMENT
MEDICAL TECHNOLOGY
HEALTH SYSTEM GOALS
HEALTH PROVIDERS
PUBLIC INSURANCE
DOCTORS
INFORMAL SECTOR
ECONOMIC ANALYSIS
PROVIDER PAYMENT
PUBLIC HEALTH
HEALTH FOR ALL
CITIES
PUBLIC HEALTH EXPENDITURES
PUBLIC SECTOR
HEALTH SYSTEM REFORM
COLLECTION OF CONTRIBUTIONS
CENTRAL GOVERNMENT BUDGET
INTERNATIONAL ORGANIZATIONS
WORKERS
UNEMPLOYMENT
INSURANCE MARKET
DATA COLLECTION
PRIVATE SECTORS
MEDICAL BENEFITS
SOCIAL INSURANCE
EXPENDITURES
MEDICAL TECHNOLOGY ASSESSMENT
PRIVATE INSURANCE
HEALTH SECTOR
SICK LEAVE
INSURERS
EXCESSIVE CONSUMPTION
BUDGET CEILINGS
PHARMACEUTICAL EXPENDITURE
HEALTH CENTERS
MORAL HAZARD
DEATHS
HEALTH FINANCING
IMMUNIZATION
CENTRAL GOVERNMENT
HOUSEHOLD EXPENDITURE
COMMUNICABLE DISEASES
HEALTH COVERAGE
INSURANCE PLANS
HEALTH SYSTEMS
MEDICAL STAFF
HEALTH REFORMS
SOCIAL SECURITY
AGING
DATA AVAILABILITY
EXPENDITURE LEVELS
INFORMED DECISIONS
STATE BUDGET
PRIMARY HEALTH CARE
PLASTIC SURGERY
HEALTH CARE EXPENDITURE
FISCAL PRESSURES
ECONOMIC GROWTH
INSURANCE COMPANIES
HOSPITAL PHARMACIES
NATIONAL HEALTH
HEALTH CARE FACILITIES
HEALTH STATUS INDICATORS
HOSPITAL SECTOR
INFORMAL SECTOR WORKERS
HEALTH INFORMATION
HEALTHCARE INSTITUTIONS
PRIVATE PHARMACIES
COST-EFFECTIVENESS
HEALTH INSURANCE FUNDS
PUBLIC EXPENDITURE ON HEALTH
SOCIAL INSURANCE SYSTEM
HEALTHCARE EXPENDITURES
DEMAND FOR SERVICES
HEALTH CARE PROVIDERS
HEALTH EXPENDITURES
GENERAL REVENUES
COMPARISONS OF HEALTH CARE EXPENDITURE
INFORMATION SYSTEM
MEDICAL DOCTORS
ACCESS TO HEALTH CARE
CONTRIBUTION RATE
PURCHASER-PROVIDER SPLIT
SOCIAL HEALTH INSURANCE
HEALTH POLICY
HEALTH INSURANCE FUND
CAPITAL INVESTMENTS
DELIVERY SYSTEM
INCOME
POCKET PAYMENTS
FINANCIAL COSTS
PRESCRIPTION DRUGS
INFECTIOUS DISEASES
INPATIENT CARE
DONOR FUNDING
MEDICAL SERVICES
HEALTH INFORMATION SYSTEMS
FINANCIAL INCENTIVE
PUBLIC FUNDING
HEALTH CARE SERVICES
HEALTH STATUS
PUBLIC RESOURCES
NATIONAL RESOURCES
PUBLIC HEALTH SYSTEM
INFORMATION SYSTEMS
OUTPATIENT CARE
AGGREGATE PUBLIC EXPENDITURE
DONOR FUNDS
HEALTHCARE SECTOR
ADMINISTRATIVE COSTS
SHARE OF HEALTH EXPENDITURE
MEDICINES
COMPETITIVE BIDDING
CONTRIBUTION RATES
PRIMARY CARE
MEDICAL FACILITIES
SOCIAL INSURANCE CONTRIBUTIONS
EXERCISES
HUMAN DEVELOPMENT
HEALTH SYSTEM
PRICE CONTROLS
PUBLIC SPENDING
HEALTH CARE INSTITUTIONS
INCOME COUNTRIES
Full record
Show full item recordOnline Access
http://hdl.handle.net/10986/7377Abstract
This paper explores the major challenges
 to the sustainability of health sector financing in the
 countries of the Western Balkans - Albania, Bosnia and
 Herzegovina, the Former Yugoslav Republic of Macedonia,
 Montenegro, Serbia and the province of Kosovo. It focuses on
 how the incentives created by the different elements of the
 healthcare financing system affect the behavior of
 healthcare providers and individuals, and the resulting
 inefficiencies in revenue collection and expenditure
 containment. The paper analyzes patterns of healthcare
 expenditure, finding that there is some evidence of cost
 containment, but that current expenditure levels - while
 similar to that in EU countries as a share of GDP - are low
 in per capita terms and the fiscal space to increase
 expenditures is extremely limited. It also examines the key
 drivers of current healthcare expenditure and the most
 significant barriers to revenue generation, identifying some
 key health reforms that countries in the sub-region could
 consider in order to enhance the efficiency and
 sustainability of their health systems. Data are drawn from
 international databases, country institutions, and household surveys.Date
2012-06-07Type
Publications & ResearchIdentifier
oai:openknowledge.worldbank.org:10986/7377http://hdl.handle.net/10986/7377
Copyright/License
CC BY 3.0 IGOCollections
Related items
Showing items related by title, author, creator and subject.
-
Enhancing Efficiency and Equity : Challenges and Reform Opportunities Facing Health and Pension Systems in the Western BalkansGragnolati, Michele; Bredenkamp, Caryn; Ramljak, Vedad; Gragnolati, Michele; Ramljak, Vedad; Bredenkamp, Caryn (World Bank, Washington, DC, 2013-05-30)This collection of papers explores the
 major challenges to the sustainability of health and pension
 system financing in the countries of the Western Balkans -
 Albania, Bosnia and Herzegovina, the Former Yugoslav
 Republic of Macedonia, Montenegro, Serbia, and the province
 of Kosovo. It focuses on how the incentives created by the
 different elements of the financing arrangements affect the
 behavior of providers and individuals, and the resulting
 inefficiencies in revenue collection and expenditure
 containment. The volume commences with an analysis of
 healthcare financing, exploring patterns of healthcare
 expenditure, and examining the key drivers of current
 healthcare expenditure and the most significant barriers to
 revenue generation. Subsequent chapters give special
 attention to provider payment mechanisms and the
 pharmaceutical sector. Equity considerations are highlighted
 in a chapter that explores the protection that is offered
 against the financial impact of health expenditures. With
 respect to the pension sector, the volume provides an
 overview of national pension systems and outlines the main
 challenges to achieving a sustainable balance between
 pension benefits and costs. The analyses of the health and
 pension reform process are placed within the context of the
 labor market challenges in the sub-region, especially as
 they relate to the ability to raise revenue for health and
 pensions through payroll contributions. All chapters
 conclude by identifying some reforms that countries in the
 sub-region could consider in order to enhance the efficiency
 and sustainability of their systems. Data are drawn from
 international databases, country institutions, and household surveys.
-
Kosovo : Health Financing Reform StudyWorld Bank (Washington, DC, 2012-06-14)The objective of this report is to present information on the different health financing reform options available to Kosovo, which can help the government to make informed policy decisions about financing reforms. The report focuses on the key insurance functions of revenue collection and management, risk pooling, and purchasing of health care, as well as the supportive regulatory and governance framework for health financing. Kosovo aims to reform health financing by moving toward a health insurance system. To implement the proposed single insurer as described in the health law, a draft law for health insurance was discussed in Parliament in 2004. The draft law envisioned the revenue sources for the future health insurance as follows: (i) 60 percent of Health Insurance Fund (HIF) revenue will be paid by the general budget; (ii) 13.5 percent will come from payroll contributions; (iii) 21 percent will come from direct payments by patients in the form of user fees; and (iv) 6.5 percent will come from patients' co-payments. Three years later, in April 2007, the Kosovo Parliament approved a health insurance law to introduce social health insurance (SHI) financed predominantly through payroll taxes, though it did not specify contribution levels. The revenue potential of such payroll funded insurance was estimated to be modest considering Kosovo's relatively small formal sector and employment rate. The Kosovo health system is predominantly tax funded. Government health spending is about 3 percent of gross domestic product (GDP) and 10 percent of general government expenditures. The ministry of economics and finance (MEF) transfer's health funds from the central budget to hospitals (51 percent), to municipalities in the form of an earmarked health grant for the provision of primary health care (PHC) services (26 percent), and to the ministry of health (MOH) for other services (22 percent) (MEF 2007).
-
Expanding Health Coverage for Vulnerable Groups in IndiaNagpal, Somil (World Bank, Washington, DC, 2013-05-02)India's health sector continues to be challenged by overall low levels of public financing, entrenched accountability issues in the public delivery system, and the persistent dominance of out-of-pocket spending. In this context, this case study describes three recent initiatives introduced by the central and state governments in India, aimed at addressing some of these challenges and improving the availability of and access to health services, particularly for the poor and vulnerable groups in the country. This includes two federal schemes introduced by the Government of India-the National Rural Health Mission (NRHM) of the Ministry of Health and Family Welfare and the Rashtriya Swasthya Bima Yojana (RSBY) of the Ministry of Labor and Employment-and the Rajiv Aarogyasri scheme launched by the state government of Andhra Pradesh. The three schemes discussed in this case study were designed and implemented by different agencies almost in parallel, over the same time period, and used different financing and delivery approaches. A discussion of the mechanics and operational features of these programs has been undertaken to unravel the underlying complexities, interactions, and interdependencies of these programs within the country's health system. The remainder of this case study on India's march toward universal health coverage focuses on three recent, prominent programs, and includes a discussion on the institutional structure of these programs and their interactions within the country's health system, their mechanisms for beneficiary targeting and enrolment, the benefits packages covered by them, accompanying innovations in public financial management, and their information environment. Annex one presents an overview of the health system and health financing in India, and annex two discusses the evolutionary context of India's Government sponsored health insurance schemes. The discussion of the mechanics and operational features of these programs has been undertaken to unravel the underlying complexities, interactions, and interdependencies within these programs. The case study also aims to contribute to the ongoing debate within the Indian health sector, with opinions divided between investments in traditional input-based health spending for publicly managed health facilities versus demand-side financing, purchasing of care, and involving private providers and intermediaries in delivering services financed by public money. The case study also aims to share how the lessons learned by one program can be applicable more widely within the Indian health system and beyond