The Political Economy of the Middle Class in the Dominican Republic : Individualization of Public Goods, Lack of Institutional Trust and Weak Collective Action
Keywords
FINANCIAL ASSETSPOLICY DISCUSSIONS
PUBLIC GOODS
PUBLIC SECTOR
PUBLIC USE
CITIZEN
FINANCIAL SHOCKS
RADIO
PUBLIC SERVICES
EDUCATION POLICIES
PUBLIC HEALTH EXPENDITURE
CENTRAL BANK
SOCIOECONOMIC STATUS
MUNICIPAL GOVERNMENT
HOUSEHOLD LEVEL
PUBLIC RESOURCES
TELEVISION
CENTRAL GOVERNMENT
CITIZENS
MORTALITY
SERVICE PROVISION
ECONOMIC INEQUALITY
VULNERABILITY
SOCIAL COHESION
RELIGIOUS GROUPS
NATIONAL INSURANCE
POLICY MAKERS
PROGRESS
ACCOUNTABILITY
MATERNAL MORTALITY
HEALTH SERVICES
INTERNATIONAL FOOD POLICY RESEARCH INSTITUTE
FINANCIAL PROBLEMS
EXPENDITURES
PUBLIC ACCOUNTABILITY
GOOD GOVERNANCE
ACCOUNTABILITY SYSTEMS
FAMILIES
MINISTRY OF ECONOMY
TAX ADMINISTRATION
AGED
ALLOCATION
PRIVATE SECTOR
ABSENTEEISM
SOCIAL SERVICES
ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT
QUALITY SERVICE
ENERGY CONSUMPTION
TAX REFORM
SECONDARY SCHOOLS
WORKFORCE
PUBLIC EXPENDITURE
QUALITY OF EDUCATION
WELFARE STATE
FINANCIAL CRISIS
PUBLIC TRANSPORTATION
WORKING POPULATION
POLITICAL PARTIES
CIVIL SOCIETY ORGANIZATIONS
HUMAN CAPITAL
PATIENT
INFANT MORTALITY RATES
PUBLIC SERVICE
EXPENDITURE
SOCIAL POLICIES
SOCIAL PROTECTION
PUBLIC SERVICE DELIVERY
REPUBLIC
PRIVATE GOODS
GDP
HOUSEHOLD SURVEYS
PUBLIC GRID
DEMOCRACY
ENFORCEMENT MECHANISMS
SUPPLY SYSTEMS
TAX
ACCOUNTABILITY MECHANISMS
HEALTH CARE
ALLOCATION OF RESOURCES
WORKERS
ELECTRICITY
CITIZEN PARTICIPATION
NUMBER OF PEOPLE
PUBLIC ADMINISTRATION
HEALTH EXPENDITURE
PUBLIC OPINION
MUNICIPAL AUTHORITIES
DEVELOPING COUNTRIES
POVERTY LEVEL
NATIONAL ACCOUNTS
LEVEL OF EDUCATION
SPOUSE
POLITICAL PARTICIPATION
INTERNATIONAL ORGANIZATIONS
MARKET FAILURES
LIMITED RESOURCES
BASIC SERVICES
PUBLIC HEALTH SYSTEM
QUALITY SERVICES
PURCHASING POWER PARITY
PUBLIC BUDGET
HOSPITALS
POVERTY ASSESSMENT
TRANSPARENCY
COLLECTIVE ACTION
INFANT MORTALITY
SURGERY
TOTAL SPENDING
HEALTH EXPENDITURES
POLICY RESEARCH WORKING PAPER
POLITICAL ECONOMY
BENEFICIARIES
PRIVATE INVESTMENT
HOSPITAL
REMITTANCES
HEALTH SECTOR
RESPECT
EDUCATION SERVICES
REDISTRIBUTION OF INCOME
VICIOUS CYCLE
PUBLIC
INFANT
SERVICE PROVIDERS
INCOME DISTRIBUTION
RISK MANAGEMENT
HEALTH INSURANCE
DEVELOPMENT POLICY
ACCESS TO INFORMATION
SOCIAL INSURANCE
SOCIAL ASSISTANCE
PUBLIC FINANCES
POLICY IMPLICATIONS
SOCIAL NETWORKS
PUBLIC HEALTH
MATERNAL MORTALITY RATE
CLINICS
PRIVATE SPENDING
FAMILY MEMBERS
PURCHASING POWER
PUBLIC PROVISION
PRIMARY EDUCATION
LABOUR FORCE
QUALITY STANDARDS
PRIVATE CONSUMPTION
ACCOUNTABILITY MECHANISM
PUBLIC EDUCATION
EDUCATION SYSTEM
LOCAL GOVERNMENT SERVICES
POLITICIANS
QUALITY OF SERVICES
DISEASES
LARGER FAMILIES
ECONOMIC GROWTH
HEALTH CARE PROVIDERS
POLICY RESEARCH
CAPACITY BUILDING
LIQUIDITY
ECONOMIC POLICIES
SOCIAL CAPITAL
PUBLIC INSTITUTIONS
PUBLIC SCHOOLS
CIVIC PARTICIPATION
PUBLIC SECTOR SERVICE DELIVERY
PUBLIC CONTRACTS
HOUSEHOLD INCOME
LIVING CONDITIONS
PUBLIC SPENDING
STREETS
PRIVATE HANDS
TAX COLLECTION
FINANCIAL MANAGEMENT
PUBLIC EXPENDITURES
MEDICINES
Full record
Show full item recordOnline Access
http://hdl.handle.net/10986/6052Abstract
This paper tries to uncover some of the hidden factors behind poor public service delivery in the Dominican Republic. By looking at three sector cases, education, health and electricity, it is possible to observe that in this setting of low quality of public services the "middle class" is opting out from the system and adopting private solutions to collective problems. The combination of this opting out behavior with low levels of institutional trust, especially among "middle class" members, fragmented interests and clientelism, among other factors, results in weak collective action and lack of effective demand for improvements in service provision. Some of the tentative policy options to break this sub-optimal equilibrium are i) to build capacity in civil society organizations and help them forming a pro-reform coalition, ii) reduce the gap between the middle class and the poorer by trying to improve the provision of public goods and enlarging the welfare state, and (iii) increase transparency mechanisms and introduce e-government formulas in order to optimize the allocation of public resources.Date
2012-04-27Identifier
oai:openknowledge.worldbank.org:10986/6052http://hdl.handle.net/10986/6052
Copyright/License
Attribution 3.0 United StatesRelated items
Showing items related by title, author, creator and subject.
-
The Political Economy of the Middle
 Class in the Dominican Republic : Individualization of
 Public Goods, Lack of Institutional Trust and Weak
 Collective ActionSenderowitsch, Roby; Sánchez, Miguel Eduardo (World Bank, Washington, DC, 2012-04-27)This paper tries to uncover some of the
 hidden factors behind poor public service delivery in the
 Dominican Republic. By looking at three sector cases,
 education, health and electricity, it is possible to observe
 that in this setting of low quality of public services the
 "middle class" is opting out from the system and
 adopting private solutions to collective problems. The
 combination of this opting out behavior with low levels of
 institutional trust, especially among "middle
 class" members, fragmented interests and clientelism,
 among other factors, results in weak collective action and
 lack of effective demand for improvements in service
 provision. Some of the tentative policy options to break
 this sub-optimal equilibrium are i) to build capacity in
 civil society organizations and help them forming a
 pro-reform coalition, ii) reduce the gap between the middle
 class and the poorer by trying to improve the provision of
 public goods and enlarging the welfare state, and (iii)
 increase transparency mechanisms and introduce e-government
 formulas in order to optimize the allocation of public resources.
-
Uzbekistan - Assessment of the Primary Health Care Reform :
 Transparency, Accountability and EfficiencyWorld Bank (World Bank, 2012-03-19)The main purpose of this report is to
 assess the degree to which progress has been made by the
 Government of Uzbekistan in increasing the transparency,
 accountability, and efficiency of its primary health
 services, and to identify what further steps could be taken
 to improve the effectiveness of delivery, some of which may
 be applicable to other sectors as well. The report examines
 public spending, public financial management, and human
 resource management and remuneration in the primary health
 care sector at the local level. It draws lessons from the
 experience of Ferghana and Samarkand, two oblasts that have
 implemented reforms in primary health care, and incorporates
 the findings drawn from other sources, such as public
 expenditure data, the laws and regulations governing these
 systems, and the Service Quality Delivery Survey (SQDS)
 conducted in 2007. This report discusses the key governance
 issues related to improving service delivery in the primary
 health care area, and concludes with recommendations
 tailored to decision makers at the central and local
 government levels and those in local facilities.
-
The Nuts & Bolts of Jamkesmas, Indonesia’s Government-Financed Health Coverage Program for the Poor and Near-PoorTandon, Ajay; Pigazzini, Anna; Harimurti, Pandu; Pambudi, Eko (World Bank, Washington DC, 2013-05-06)This case study describes and assesses Jamkesmas, Indonesia's government-financed health coverage program for the poor and near-poor. It provides a detailed description of the scope, depth, and breadth of coverage provided under Jamkesmas, and highlights ways in which the program interacts with the rest of Indonesia's health system. It also summarizes and discusses evidence on whether Jamkesmas is attaining its stated objectives of removing financial barriers and improving access to health care by the poor and near-poor, what could be improved, and what lessons can be learned from the experience of Jamkesmas that could help inform Indonesia's quest for universal coverage. The primary theme underlying the study is that supply-side constraints and supply-side subsidies have not been leveraged to increase the effectiveness of the Jamkesmas program. There are significant geographic deficiencies in the availability and quality of the basic benefits package, especially for those living in relatively remote and rural locations of the country, and this limits the effective availability of benefits for many Jamkesmas beneficiaries. The remainder of the case study is organized as follows. Section two provides general background and information on health system outcomes in Indonesia. Section three is an overview of health care financing and delivery. Section four describes the institutional architecture of Jamkesmas. Section five highlights the process of targeting, identification, and enrolment of beneficiaries under the program. Section six focuses on the role of public financing. Section seven outlines the basic benefits package. Section eight provides an overview of the information environment of Jamkesmas. Section nine discusses the special theme of supply-side constraints and supply-side subsidies that dilute the effectiveness of the Jamkesmas program. Section ten discusses the pending agenda around some of the architectural and operational features of Jamkesmas in the context of universal coverage.