Private Participation in the Transport Sector : Lessons from Recent Experience in Europe and Central Asia
Keywords
REGIONAL TRANSPORTGOVERNMENT FINANCING
RAPID DEVELOPMENT
VALUABLE
FINANCIAL ANALYSIS
INTERNATIONAL AIRPORT
INFORMATION ASYMMETRY
STATE PROPERTY
RECESSION
ROAD NETWORK
MATURE CAPITAL MARKETS
SAFETY
INTERNATIONAL BANK
PRODUCTIVITY
VEHICLE
HIGHWAYS
PRIVATE PARTIES
RETURN ON EQUITY
TRANSPORT INVESTMENT
DEBT
GROSS DOMESTIC PRODUCT
PRIVATE INVESTMENT
HIGHWAY
TRAM
PUBLIC SERVICE PROVISION
RENEGOTIATIONS
TRANSPORT
CONTRACT RENEGOTIATION
CONGESTION
LLC
LEGAL ENVIRONMENT
MARKET ECONOMY
TRAFFIC LEVELS
TREATY
DEVELOPING COUNTRIES
TRANSACTION
BEST PRACTICES
FOREIGN EXCHANGE RISK
PRIVATE FINANCE
TRANSITION COUNTRIES
TECHNICAL ASSISTANCE
INVESTMENT ACTIVITY
PROFITABILITY
SHAREHOLDERS
RETURN ON INVESTMENT
CAPITAL MARKETS
MATURITY
PUBLIC AGENCIES
CAPACITY BUILDING
TOLL COLLECTION
ROAD INFRASTRUCTURE
CONTRACT RENEGOTIATIONS
PRIVATE FINANCING
RAILWAYS
ROAD SECTOR
HOLDING
RECURRENT EXPENDITURE
TRANSPORT INVESTMENTS
LANES
MACROECONOMIC CONDITIONS
COST OF CAPITAL
POOR CREDIT RATING
CONTRIBUTIONS
ROAD
DRIVERS
CAPITAL FLOWS
TOLLS
DEBT REPAYMENT
LEGAL FRAMEWORK
GOVERNMENT SUPPORT
RISK SHARING
BID
CREDIT RATINGS
DEBT SERVICE
ASSET MANAGEMENT
TRANSPARENCY
LEGISLATION
INTERNATIONAL FINANCIAL INSTITUTIONS
LEVY
PRESENT VALUE
GOVERNMENT POLICY
BORROWING
CONTRIBUTION
SUBSIDIARY
ROAD SYSTEM
INVESTMENT PROGRAMS
ACCOUNTING
LENDERS
POVERTY ALLEVIATION
RETURNS
FINANCIAL CRISIS
POTENTIAL INVESTORS
MUNICIPALITIES
FINANCIAL DISTRESS
PRIVATE PARTY
PUBLIC SERVICES
INTERNATIONAL FINANCIAL INSTITUTION
PASSENGER TRANSPORT
INTERNAL RATE OF RETURN
LAWS
TOLL MOTORWAYS
INSTRUMENT
FISCAL DISCIPLINE
LEGISLATIVE FRAMEWORK
FREE ROADS
HIGHWAY NETWORK
INSTITUTIONAL CAPACITY
SAVINGS
EXPENDITURES
RISK MITIGATION
INFRASTRUCTURE INVESTMENT
FINANCIAL CRISES
PUBLIC GOOD
ROAD PROJECTS
PRIVATE TRANSPORT
CREDIT ENHANCEMENT
BALANCE SHEET
DEMAND FOR TRANSPORT
TRANSPORT NETWORK
TRAFFIC VOLUMES
DRIVING
COLLATERAL
TRANSPORT INFRASTRUCTURE
INFLATION RATE
TRANSIT
TOLL ROAD
NATIONAL ECONOMIES
PRIVATE INVESTORS
CALCULATIONS
MINISTRIES OF FINANCE
STAKEHOLDERS
TRANSPORT PROJECTS
FISCAL CONSTRAINTS
CHECKS
TOTAL ANNUAL INVESTMENT
MOTORWAYS
INVESTING
INTERNATIONAL TRADE LAW
MATURITIES
RISK MANAGEMENT
LOCAL GOVERNMENTS
PUBLIC DEBT
PRIVATE SECTOR INVESTMENT
ALTERNATIVE ROUTES
TAXATION
DEVELOPMENT BANK
TRANSACTION COSTS
FISCAL POSITIONS
CONTINGENT LIABILITIES
GOVERNMENT BUDGET
INTERNATIONAL CAPITAL
TOTAL COST
RENEGOTIATION
TOLL MOTORWAY
EMERGING MARKETS
POLITICAL UNCERTAINTY
PUBLIC INVESTMENT
TRANSPORT SYSTEMS
FINANCIAL RESOURCES
EXPENDITURE
ECONOMICS
FOREIGN EXCHANGE
INTERNATIONAL TRADE
CAPITAL INVESTMENTS
RISK PROFILE
CONTRACT LAW
TREASURY
CARS
LIABILITY
INCOME
ANNUAL PAYMENTS
QUANTITATIVE ANALYSIS
PRIVATE FUNDS
DEPRECIATION
DEBT FINANCING
TOLL
TRAFFIC
WORTH
DEBT SERVICING
CREDIT RATING
RAILROADS
RAILWAY SECTOR
MONETARY FUND
ENFORCEMENT OF CONTRACT
FINANCIAL INSTITUTIONS
INFLATION
POOR CREDIT
ROADS
REGULATORY FRAMEWORK
INVESTMENT BANK
MAJOR ASSET
PERFORMANCE RISK
ROAD USERS
DIVERSIFICATION
TOLL ROADS
TRAFFIC DEMAND
INVESTMENT PROJECTS
PUBLIC FINANCE
AIRPORTS
BUSINESS CYCLE
RAILWAY
BASIC COST
DEBT-SERVICE
CASH FLOW
INTEREST RATE
LEGAL PROTECTIONS
TELECOMMUNICATIONS
ECONOMIC ACTIVITY
FINANCIAL SUPPORT
COMPETITIVE BIDDING
FOREIGN INVESTMENT
ROAD USE
TRANSPORT SECTOR
FINANCIAL TROUBLE
TRAFFIC RISK
BUDGET DEFICIT
FOREIGN CURRENCY
EIB
VEHICLES
INFRASTRUCTURE INVESTMENTS
INFRASTRUCTURE PROJECTS
GLOBAL BUSINESS
DOUBLE TAXATION
ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT
Full record
Show full item recordOnline Access
http://hdl.handle.net/10986/17462Abstract
This report was commissioned to draw
 lessons from the experiences with public private
 partnerships (PPPs) in the transport sector in Europe and
 Central Asia (ECA) countries. The report will review
 experiences to date with private participation in the
 transport sector with a primary focus on experiences in the
 ECA countries and Europe. To carefully prepare and select
 the most desirable PPP projects during the most severe
 economic downturn since the Second World War, availability
 of regional best practices would be helpful. This report
 will provide guidance for successful PPP implementation and
 will hopefully encourage public authorities to critically
 evaluate their project designs. The lessons from this study
 apply regardless of the financial crisis. While the dire
 economic environment will considerably impact the current
 PPP pipeline, the fundamental success factors for these
 projects will remain the same. During times of economic
 turmoil, evaluating past investment projects can provide
 lessons for stimulating the next period of economic growth.
 The report discusses the impact of the financial crisis
 separately in annex B.Date
2014-03-28Type
Publications & Research :: Working PaperIdentifier
oai:openknowledge.worldbank.org:10986/17462http://hdl.handle.net/10986/17462
Copyright/License
CC BY 3.0 IGOCollections
Related items
Showing items related by title, author, creator and subject.
-
Fostering the Development of Greenfield Mining-related Transport Infrastructure through Project FinancingPublic-Private Infrastructure Advisory Facility; International Finance Corporation (World Bank, Washington, DC, 2013-09-19)The purpose of this study is to serve as
 a guide on developing Greenfield transport infrastructure
 (rail and port) primarily used to support mining operations
 ('mining-related infrastructure'), through
 Public-Private Partnership (PPP) schemes and on a project
 finance basis. The focus is on key financing issues and
 considerations, as well as recommendations for governments
 and private-sector participants, specifically in the context
 of sub-Saharan Africa and similar regions. Over the past
 decade, the rapid economic growth in newly industrialized
 markets has fueled a strong demand for various commodities
 (such as iron, coal, bauxite and copper), with significant
 impact on their prices. The last ten years have seen an
 unprecedented rise in the price of mineral commodities
 worldwide. From the mid-2000s through the early 2010s, the
 world's largest mining companies embarked in the
 planning of numerous and often very large mining projects to
 satisfy what was seen as an ever growing double digit demand
 for minerals (iron ore, coal, bauxite, copper, etc). A
 number of these mining projects are located in frontier
 countries (e.g. Mongolia, Guinea, Afghanistan, Sierra Leone
 and Mozambique). This report explores the challenges and
 solutions associated with the development of Greenfield
 mining-related transport infrastructure through project
 financing in frontier countries, including as shared-use
 assets. From an ownership and financing structure
 perspective, there are three traditional forms of ownership
 models: public-sector led, mining company-led or third-party
 investment. Given that most frontier host governments simply
 do not have the ability to fund these infrastructure
 projects on a purely public basis (including with the
 assistance of multilateral development banks), this report
 focuses on the latter two ownership arrangements. In terms
 of financing models, the size of such investments often
 rules out corporate financing as a viable option for
 external investors. Thus project financing is the most
 feasible and most adapted form of debt financing for
 Greenfield multi-user/multi-client mining-related
 infrastructure, assuming project bankability can be
 demonstrated to lenders. Lastly, public authorities might
 have to accept that multi-usage demands made to transport
 mining infrastructure operators might have to be initially
 or permanently restricted to secure, first and foremost, the
 delivery of an efficient mining transport system at the
 lowest possible cost to its anchor user/client.
-
Private Sector Participation in
 Light Rail-Light Metro Transit InitiativesMandri-Perrott, Cledan; Menzies, Iain (World Bank, 2012-03-19)This book aims to help governments and
 public authorities to establish effective light rail-light
 metro transit (LRMT) systems, and focuses on use of
 Public-Private Participation (PPP) arrangements. Rather than
 identify a single approach, authors present options and
 discuss practical issues related to preparing and
 implementing new LRMT PPP schemes. The approach is focused
 on providing information that can be used to make informed
 decisions, adapted to local policy and objectives. The
 material presented is intended as a practical guide to
 developing LRMT PPPs in both developed and developing
 countries. This work endeavors to provide answers to
 readers' questions regarding how to successfully
 incorporate private sector participation in LRMT with a
 lesser emphasis on why LRMT and the private sector may be
 beneficial. The primary focus of this text is guiding the
 reader from design through to project implementation. It
 starts from the premise that underlying transport policy
 decisions will have already been made and that LRMT has
 already been identified as the appropriate transport
 solution. The authors have included some limited discussion
 of policy and technical issues where these directly impact
 the LRMT PPP approach. The approach is presented in nine
 sections, and in preparing it the author drew on current
 international LRMT PPP experience, through a series of
 interviews and case studies. The sections covered are: 1)
 urban transport and LRMT: an overview of urban transport
 policy, the characteristics of LRMT schemes and the
 influences on LRMT policies; 2) technical issues: a brief
 review of some key technical issues inherent in LRMT schemes
 and their potential impact on PPP design and implementation;
 3) incorporating private sector participation in LRMT
 initiatives: what PPP has to offer, and an overview of the
 issues and stages public authorities follow to establish
 successful LRMT PPP arrangements; 4) understanding and
 managing risk: analyzing and allocating risks and
 responsibilities among stakeholders in the LRMT scheme and
 practical ways of designing risk allocation rules; 5) PPP,
 design, specifications and performance management: setting
 service standards and specifications and establishing
 associated costs; developing of performance and payment
 indicators and managing compliance; 6) funding and finance:
 large LRMT capital and system maintenance requirements
 require strong financing arrangements. The practical use of
 public and private financing mechanisms under PPP
 arrangement is reviewed; 7) developing a PPP agreement:
 looking at the main types of PPP agreements, an outline
 framework for developing the contractual arrangement is
 developed through re-view of key issues; 8) procurement:
 reviewing the approaches that the public authority can use
 to select the private partner; and 9) conclusions.
-
Public-Private Partnerships in Europe and Central Asia : Designing Crisis-Resilient Strategies and Bankable ProjectsMandri-Perrott, Cledan; Cuttaree, Vickram (World Bank, 2012-03-19)This study aims to help governments
 design sustainable Public-Private Partnership (PPP)
 strategies and projects in the context of the changed
 circumstances brought on by the global financial and
 economic crisis that began in the fall of 2008. The study
 analyses the impact and implication of the crisis on PPP
 infrastructure projects across the Europe and Central Asia
 (ECA) region. In the research undertaken for this study, it
 appears that most crisis-specific issues are cross-sectoral,
 therefore requiring cross-sectoral responses. The intended
 audience for this report includes national government
 stakeholders involved in infrastructure financing, including
 Ministries in charge of infrastructure, especially
 transport, energy, and water; state-owned enterprises with
 operational responsibilities, such as road directorates; and
 Ministries of Finance and development banks involved in PPP.
 This report reviewed the region's experience in PPPs in
 infrastructure before and during the financial crisis period
 (from late 2006 to 2010). Since not all ECA countries have
 had successful or ongoing PPP projects during this time, the
 report draws on lessons from Brazil, India, Spain, and the
 United Kingdom, countries with established PPP project
 pipelines to draw on cross-sectoral lessons. The findings
 can be used by countries wishing to start or re-start their
 PPP program following the impact of the recent crisis.
 However, beyond the crisis and its effects, the report can
 also guide future development of sustainable and
 crisis-resilient PPP programs. Most of the analysis
 supporting the report recommendations was undertaken for the
 highway sector and was financed through from a grant from
 the transport research support program. Initially, the
 highway sector was the focus of this study but the scope was
 later widened to include all infrastructure sectors because
 most issues facing highway PPP projects are common to other
 sectors requiring a cross-sectoral approach to PPP.
 Sector-specific strategies for highways have been documented
 in a recent World Bank study.