Gambling with the public sphere: Accounting's contribution to debate on social issues.
Keywords150100 ACCOUNTING AUDITING AND ACCOUNTABILITY
Full recordShow full item record
AbstractThis paper explores the contribution of accounts, especially counter-accounts, to the debate on social issues in the public sphere. We examine a social activist organisation's challenge to a major corporation to acknowledge the issue of problem gambling and change its poker machine operations. While the professionally sanctioned corporate financial statements and corporate responsibility reports failed to contribute relevant information for an informed public debate, the activist organisation sponsored and produced both narrative and calculative counter-accounts which contributed to public debate. We initially anchor our approach in Habermas' to explore dialogic accounts and democratic accountability at the deliberative-agonistic divide. Our contextualised, theorised narrative identifies the accounts and counter-accounts provided by the protagonists. Practically, the paper demonstrates the power of counter-accounts to reinvigorate debate in the public sphere, irrespective of whether it stimulates a change in corporate behaviour. We therefore contend that social accounting should be empirically examined and contextually interpreted. The case brings into focus the deliberative-agonistic divide inherent in democratic systems and recognised in the social accounting literature, and suggests that ideological differences make it difficult for corporate and activist protagonists to co-exist as friendly enemies. This challenges Habermas' conception of a public sphere as naively idealistic, since it neglects contemporary ideological, political and power differentials, but proposes a space in which debate about accounting's role in social issues can be agonistically debated. It leads us to call for more theoretically informed, contextualised case studies to examine the potential of accounting to enable public debate on social issues.
Copyright/LicenseCrown Copyright 2017 Published by Elsevier Ltd.
Showing items related by title, author, creator and subject.
Local Public Financial ManagementShah, Anwar (Washington, DC: World Bank, 2012-05-30)This volume provides an overview of local government financial accounting and reporting and where better practices in cash management are documented. The use of transparent procurement processes to mitigate corruption is also elaborated on while practical guidance is imparted on how and when to use debt, how to assess debt affordability, what debt to use, how to issue debt, and how to manage debt. The use of internal controls and audits to ensure efficiency and integrity is highlighted in this volume with particular emphasis on the role of external audit in combating corruption. Audit methods to detect corruption are also presented and discussed. The volume represents a collaborative effort of the Swedish International Development Cooperation Agency and the World Bank Institute to support reform of the public expenditure management and financial accountability systems in developing countries, especially in Africa.
El Salvador : Accounting and AuditingWorld Bank (Washington, DC, 2012-06-22)This report provides an assessment of accounting and auditing practices within El Salvador's corporate sector. It used International Financial Reporting Standards (IFRS) and International Standards on Auditing (ISA) as benchmarks, and drew on international experience and good practices in those fields. Both statutory requirements and actual practices were analyzed as part of this review. The purpose of this ROSC is to assist the Government of El Salvador in strengthening the private sector's accounting and auditing practices and financial transparency. The development objectives these efforts address are (a) fostering the growth and accountability of the private sector, (b) ensuring adequate market regulation with respect to the provision of essential services, and (c) making the business environment more attractive for foreign direct investment (FDI). The recommendations of this ROSC are intended to serve as the basis for a country action plan to be developed by the Government of El Salvador in collaboration with in-country stakeholders and with the assistance of the World Bank and other donors.
Strengthening Financial Reporting Regimes and the Accountancy Profession and Practices in Selected Caribbean CountriesWorld Bank Group (World Bank, Washington, DC, 2015-08-18)The main objectives of this report are
to: (a) provide a synthesized analysis of financial
reporting and auditing standards and practices across the
countries in which the Institute of Chartered Accountants of
the Caribbean (ICAC) is active and (b) provide a basis for
recommendations to ICAC and respective national institutes
for a regional strategy to enhance the accounting profession
and the accounting and auditing practices in the public and
private sectors. This report’s focus on reforms and
identification of areas and means to strengthen the
accounting profession have at their root the conviction that
systemic enhancements to the standards and practices of the
profession can materially improve the lives of the region’s
populace, particularly its less prosperous citizens, through
greater transparency, strengthened economic growth and its
attendant employment and tax revenue prospects, and greater
access to financing for and formalization of the region’s
dominant sector-micro, small, and medium-sized enterprises
(MSMEs). The report finds that a constraint limiting both
investment across the region, particularly to MSMEs that
characterize the respective national economies, and the
efficient use of public resources is the accounting and
auditing practices and the financial reporting regimes that
prevail in both the public and private sectors. This finding
emerges from: (i) a review of Reports on the Observance of
Standards and Codes for Accounting and Auditing (ROSC AA)
conducted by the World Bank for Jamaica, Trinidad and
Tobago, Suriname, and the countries of the Organisation of
Eastern Caribbean States, and (ii) Bank missions to those
countries updating the ROSC findings as well as missions to
countries that have not yet had ROSC AA reviews (during
which the Bank team met the national accountancy body,
regulators of entities that fall within the financial
reporting chain, supreme audit institutions, central banks,
and so forth so as to secure information that would
typically be found in formal ROSC AA reports).