Clinical Ethics Discussion 4
Asai, Atsushi Itai, Koichiro
Asai, Atsushi
Itai, Koichiro
Author(s)
Contributor(s)
Keywords
GE Subjects
Collections
Research Projects
Organizational Units
Journal Issue
Online Access
Abstract
No matter how far medicine advances, incurable disease will inevitably exist; and the dying patient's last resort will likewise look to medical research. In this report, we examine a case concerning the use of experimental medical therapy on a critically ill child. We discuss the ethical argument pertaining to the recommending of experimental medical therapy to the family of a dying patient. Under the circumstances of having to face the impending death of one's own child, parents of a terminally ill child are extremely vulnerable to suggestion and often loose the ability to make a composed decision._Moreover, there exists the possibility of not only patients, but also medical staff and researchers, to fall into therapeutic misconception. Likewise, for the terminal patient and his/her family though, experimental medical therapy is often the only hope, which is, however, always accompanied by a factor of uncertainty and is considered to be merely an unapproximated gamble. The proposing of experimental medical therapy can result in being cruel by shattering the parent's expectations of saving their child._ We examine the issues involved in proposing an experimental medical therapy to patients who are in dire need of a last hope; and conclude that, in times of emergency, we must take great consideration in recommending an experimental medical therapy as an "innovative treatment." In extreme circumstances where an individual's life is on the line, doing nothing can be quite trying; yet, what is right is not necessarily doing something, but rather making the right decision.
Note(s)
Topic
Type
Article
Date
2004-03
Identifier
ISBN
DOI
Copyright/License
With permission of the license/copyright holder